Air compressors serve a wide range of uses, including operating power tools and nail guns, and assisting with auto repair, inflating things, and much more. Choosing what type of air compressor to use primarily comes down to your desired application and the convenience of power sources nearby. The two primary types of air compressors to choose from are electric and gas.
What’s the difference between electric and gas air compressors? Electric air compressors will require a nearby power outlet for operation, while gas air compressors rely on gasoline to run. The primary differences between the two compressors include:
Power Source and Output
Price Point
Energy Efficiency
Noise Level
Safety Concerns
Environmental Impact
Choosing either air compressor will help you to get the job done, but each has advantages and drawbacks depending on the type and conditions of the project you are working on. This article will tackle the considerable differences between the two air compressors to determine which machine works best for your projects.
The Differences Between Electric vs. Gas Air Compressors
The differences between electric and gas air compressors are essential to consider because Both types of compressors can only be used in a specific location.
These are the significant differences we will be exploring when comparing electric and gas air compressors:
Power source and output: This includes the power required to operate them and how their power levels differ.
Price point: The cost of an air compressor has an enormous impact on consumer choices.
Energy efficiency: Comparing the amount of energy used and how this impacts the costs of operation.
Noise level: Air compressors are loud machines that may negatively impact hearing.
Safety concerns: always Varafy power inputs not doing so will result in unique safety concerns and dangers.
Environmental impact: The use of gas versus electricity has varying effects on our environmental footprint.
Let’s explore each of these categories to determine which air compressor is ideal for different working environments.
Power Source and Output of Electric vs. Gas Air Compressors
The most considerable difference between the two air compressor types is the way they are powered. Described by their name, Electric compressors needing to be powered by an electrical outlet, and gas compressors relying on gasoline or natural gas to function—the power source impacts transportability and verifies their power source.
An electric air compressor will require a nearby power source for the operation to take place. Not typically a problem for most air powered jobs, especially if you are using them for home jobs or auto repair. There may also be generators nearby to provide power to a variety of needed tools.
The gas air compressor becomes a useful alternative to electric air compressors in a rural area or far from a power source. Relying on gasoline makes it easy to take anywhere, with gas air compressors being the more portable of the two options. But gas compressors are usually much heavier as they have a gas engine attached instead of a much lighter electric motor.
Both compressors come in multiple sizes, offering similar power outputs unless you opt for a much larger gas engine that produces higher horsepower. The duration of the pressurized air also varies. Unlike electric, gas air compressors keep running at their ideal pressure zone as they run on gas. Electric compressors will automatically turn off when the pressure drops.
Price Point of Electric vs. Gas Air Compressors
Many consumers are price-sensitive when making decisions about power tools. Investing in an expensive piece of equipment that will be used frequently or purchasing an air compressor will satisfy infrequent use needs. Electric air compressors are usually less costly and more commonly used than gas air compressors.
The lower price point of an electrical air compressor comes down to less expensive technology and a smaller and more compact machine. Gas air compressors are usually much larger and heavier with an engine involved. Not only do you have to consider the more considerable initial investment in a gas air compressor, but you will also have reoccurring fuel costs.
Keep in mind that larger compressors will be more powerful and, therefore, more expensive. There is a wide discrepancy between air compressors’ pricing in the same power source category depending on the compressor’s size and the amount of pressure and power it will produce. Make sure you are comparing electric and gas tools of the same power and size.
You can expect to pay nearly double the price for a gas air compressor than an electric one. But this may be a necessary trade-off and worth the additional cost if environments where electrical power is not easily accessible or for work that will require high levels of power with a big engine that cannot be achieved by a locally available power source.
Energy Efficiency of Electric vs. Gas Air Compressors
In the context of air compressors, energy efficiency measures the differences in energy costs to complete a similar job. There are many electric air compressor variations, with some being designed specifically for greater efficiency levels. Gas air compressors can rely on gasoline or natural gases, which will vary the output and fuel costs.
Most gas air compressors use gasoline, as natural gas air compressors are typically used for:
Pipelines: Pressurized air moves contents in the pipelines from production facilities to the recipient.
Manufacturing: Many tools used in manufacturing plants are require air compression. Using natural gas is often a cheaper alternative to electricity in large plants such as
Chemical and gas plants, The use of compressing gases as an output in a wide range of applications within a plant, where an electrical discharge may cause an explosion
.
One option is not necessarily more energy efficient than the other; instead, they use energy differently, resulting in higher or lower costs based on your usage. If using natural gas will most likely be less expensive and, therefore, more efficient than electricity costs. Compared to gasoline, electricity is often a less expensive option.
For your projects, you will need to estimate the amount of work you need done and compare these to both the cost of electricity and gas. One of the primary benefits of an electric air compressor is that the initial price is lower, and you do not need to pay regular fuel costs. You will be increasing your energy bill, but only substantially if many are frequently running.
Most consumer gas air compressors will use gasoline, resulting in less energy efficiency and higher cost than natural gas and electricity-powered air compressors of similar size and power.
Noise Level of Electric vs. Gas Air Compressors
In practice, one of the most apparent differences between electric and gas air compressors is the level of noise they produce. Advancing technologies make compressors much quieter, but gas air compressors are much louder because they rely on engine combustion and more moving parts versus an electric motor that operates quietly.
Air compressors range from 40dB to 100dB in sound level, which is an extensive range. Louder machines can have negative impacts on your hearing over extended time and frequent use. One is more likely to experience hearing loss with regular use of a gas-power air compressor than the electric one.
These are the varying noise levels and characteristics of electric and gas compressors:
Electric air compressor noise: You can find compressors as low as 40dB, comparable to a quiet room, or walk around a suburban area at night. Motor technology has progressed to significantly quiet these machines.
Gas compressor noise: Gas compressors will fall at the higher end of the noise scale, with large ones falling around or slightly above 85 dB; this is comparable to city traffic or a lawnmower. Anything above 85 dB is considered harmful.
For a much quieter air compressor, electric is the best option. There are multiple ways to protect yourself and limit air compressors’ noise level, given that most will emit high levels of sound. It is recommended, especially for gas-powered ones, to wear ear protection when working closely with the machine.
Other sound reduction solutions for your air compressor include:
- Place rubber under the compressor or cover the motor with rubber to absorb vibrations that may increase noise levels.
- Creating an enclosure made of sound-dampening materials will decrease the level of noise output.
- Install a better air intake or filter housing. We recommend this for frequent air compressor use.
Taking any of these precautions will help to decrease the sound level of your air compressor. If you are currently looking for an air compressor, there are many ‘silent’ or ‘quiet’ compressors on the market.
Safety Concerns of Electric vs. Gas Air Compressors
The risks associated with using an air compressor will vary depending on the conditions of operations. Generally, electric air compressors are safer to operate because they do not rely on flammable liquid and admit toxic gases.
These are some precautions to take when operating a gas air compressor:
- Always follow the instructions that are specified by the manufacturer to keep yourself safe during operation.
- Avoid closed and confined spaces where ventilation is low, as this can lead to significant exposure to toxic chemicals.
- Only add gas when the air compressor is not running, and the engine has had a chance to cool down; this will avoid a fire or explosion.
Not only do you have to be mindful of explosions and gas-related incidents, but the emissions produced by using a gas air compressor are also harmful when inhaled. Operate Gas compressors outside, where there is no ventilation risk. Inhaling high levels of carbon monoxide is dangerous and can result in both sicknesses and, in worst cases, death.
Electric air compressors present safety concerns, but they are similar to those posed using any electrical device. It is essential to plug the compressor into a properly grounded outlet to prevent damage to the machine or a fire. Electrical fires occur due to sparks from insufficient outlets. Additionally, limit the use of long cords to prevent injury or hazards in the workspace.
You should be aware of the environment in which you are operating an electrical or gas air compressor. The highest safety standards and equipment inspections and maintenance are essential for both machines. Excessive pressure levels may lead to ruptures or explosions of the compressor vessel itself.
Environmental Impact of Electric vs. Gas Air Compressors
Trends across many machines have opted for electrical over gas-powered due to their lower environmental impact. Using an electric air compressor will result in fewer negative environmental consequences because less harmful green house gasses are
emitted into the atmosphere.
The gas engine combustion process results in the production of harmful chemicals and toxins into the environment. Running these machines contributes to air pollution, greenhouse gases, carbon monoxide, and particulate matter.
The contribution of harmful chemicals is much lower than larger gas-using machines, but if environmental impact is a primary concern, the electric air compressor serves as a greener choice. Air compressor manufacturers are improving their technology and product lines to be more energy-efficient and reduce the environmental impact.
Industrial air compressor usage has much more significant adverse consequences to the environment compared to those used by most consumers on a much smaller scale. Using electric or gas air compressors on a large scale will still favor electric in terms of emissions and environmental impact.
Which Type of Air Compressor Is Best?
Only You Can Determan the answer if you are asking this question. To help with the solution, here is a list of qualifying questions.
- what size air compressor is needed?
- how often will this compressor be in service?
- is electric power available in the location of the compressor?
- how much energy and at what cost will the compressor need?
- location of the compressor?
- is the noise a factor during use?
- cost comparison not only of equipment but of installation and cost of service?
These are general questions to be used over various industries, light off-grid home use, mobile mechanic, heavy industry with only light air use. I have run into many situations where LP gas had to be used as a backup air supply in a redundant system.
You should choose an electric air compressor for:
Power outlet proximity: As long as you are near a power outlet, you can use an electric air compressor. Avoid using extension cords as this can strain the power supply or lead to accidents.
Indoor use: Because gas air compressors emit toxic fumes, you should not use them indoors. If you need to work on projects inside, an electric air compressor is a safest and most ideal choice.
Environmental impact: Gas compressors emit chemicals into the environment while electric compressors do not. By using an electric compressor, it limits your ecological footprint.
Safety: You will not run into more likely fire hazards with an electric air compressor like you risk using gas as it is highly flammable. Gases emitted can also be harmful if inhaled over extended periods.
Infrequent use: If you do not plan to use an air compressor often or for small projects, electric options are smaller, more convenient, and less expensive. Small compressors are compact and can be easily stored, unlike large gas-powered ones.
You should choose a gas air compressor for:
Rural or remote locations: If you do not have easy access to power, a gas air compressor is an ideal option, so you can work on projects anywhere.
Power outages: In the event of a power outage, especially for time-bound projects, using a gas air compressor will not cause you to cease operation.
Temporary Need for air. Many Times When Electric Compressors Fail The simplest and most cost-effective way to get a business up and running while waiting for parts and repair is to back up a portable gas
compressor readily available at your local equipment rental, and Tee it into the existing system.
There are more reasons to justify using an electric air compressor than gas. Still, both are excellent options for providing compressed air with proper precautions and requirements for a job.
Electric air compressors are often more convenient and commonly used with a lower price point for consumers, but gas compressors offer more versatility for job locations.
The physical and applicable differences between electric and gas air compressors are derived from their power source. Impacting every factor we have mentioned throughout this article, from the level of noise each produces to the safety concerns associated with operation. These differences create priorities for choosing one compressor over the other.